St. Mary’s, Cooperstown, NY – est. 1867

April 2019 – Interim administrator and priest

2000 – Rev. John P. Rosson

1992 – Rev. John Roos

1971 – Rev. John Sise

1955 – Rev. Robert C. Murphy

1939 – Rev. Patrick Whelan

1934 – Rev.. Vincent de Paul Archambault

1920 – Rev. Patrick Crowe

1916 – Rev. John Carey

1910 – Rev. Michael Mooney

1900 – Rev. Thomas Earley

1887 – Rev. Daniel O’Connell

1879 – Rev. Martin Hughes

1870 – Rev. Matthew Devitt (poss. 1872)

1868 – Rev. J. J. Brennan

1867 – Parish formally established (no pastor listed)

1866 – Rev. John McDermott

1862 – Rev. William Carrol

1857-1865 From Amsterdam

1854 – Rev. Jonathan Furlong

1851 – Rev John Kenny (M.C. Kenny)

1850 – Rev. Lawrence Constantine, served from Hunter

1844 – Rev. Michael Gilbride, served from Saugerties